July 24, 2007
-
Aureole
New York City, NY
My New York eating binge continues with Aureole, Charlie Palmer’s fine dining establishment on Manhattan’s Upper Eastside.. I went there with pretty high expectations, I’m a big fan of Charlie Palmer.. I respect his vision and I like his style. Being that this was during restaurant week, you can’t still hold them to the same standards, can you? Yes you can, especially if 2 of the 3 people ordered off the regular menu! Let’s see what happened…
Outside Aureole.
Heirloom Tomato Amuse
Lobster Tortellini
Chilled Sweet Pea Soup
East Coast Oyters on the Half ShellThe Amuse Bouche was a Consomme of Heirloom Tomatoes. It was nice, it wasn’t spectacular but very decent. A true fan of tomatoes would have really enjoyed it. First Course I had the “Lobster Tortellini, infusion of fresh thyme and lemon grass”, I’m sorry.. I did not pick up the “lobster” on this course and the infusion was so-so. It was beautifully presented, but it lacked a depth in flavor.
My partners in crime ordered the “Chilled Sweet Pea Soup, crab crisp, lemon & pepper cream, shaved radishes” and the “East Coast Oyters on the Half Shell, green apple and cucumber mignonette, wasabi tobikko”. The pea soup.. as one of my favorite quotes from Iron Chef America goes, “There’s much “Peaness” going on here.. which is nice” lol Joking aside, this soup’s problem lied mainly in it’s portion-size. There was too much of it and you get tired of it really quickly.
The East Coast Oyters on the Half Shell was good. The oysters were fresh tasting and the cucumber migonette left an interesting /refreshing finish. It’s not how we usually do it down South but it’s different and that’s not always a bad thing, right? =)
Spiced Moulard Duck Breast
Roasted Amish Chicken
Seared Maine Sea ScallopsMain Courses… This was the “meat” of the Aureole experience! I had the “Spiced Moulard Duck Breast, confit and date “b’steeya”, spicy honey, black cumin roasted carrots”. The Duck, fruits and carrots were just perfect but the “egg roll” thing wasn’t a big hit. I’m sure it was done to create contrast in texture.. it just didn’t work for me.
The other 2 courses? “Roasted Amish Chicken, Scallion Risotto Sweet Garlic & Herb jus” and “Seared Maine Sea Scallops, crisp potato cake, Granny Smith apple brown butter”. The chicken was tasty but it wasn’t something I expected from Aureole, anywhere else it would have probably been gold! The Seared Scallops were deliciously juicy and very plump, it was practically bursting at the seams! One of the highlights of the meal..
Tasting of Chocolate Classics
Triple Chocolate Terrine
Creme Brulee Trio
The desserts were all very decadent and luscious! If you want variety, this is the way to go. A Tasting of Chocolate Classics, a Triple Chocolate Terrine, and a Creme Brulee Trio??? Whoa.. you think it’s rude to ask for a cup of milk? lol The desserts more than made up for the lackluster first couse offerings. It was a bit much, but even after this late lunch followed with a cup of coffee… food coma still came out on top. We were unable to do anything else that afternoon.. lol
New Chef Eats’ Directory:
-Entries and Entrees-
Updated regularly, So eat up! =)
Comments (15)
Even among the finest establishments, it’s rare to find a fully satisfying experience at every course. But as long as the main course delivers and dessert ends well, I might be able to forgive a bad first course. I’ll definitely be trying this place out soon. Thanks for the review!
the tomato amuse, scallops and desserts would’ve been enough for me… the choco terrine looks amazing…
being a pastry chef seems like fun creating all the pretty lil things but i fear becoming obese lol
yummm…
the tomato amuse does not look appealing at all to me..
but dessert? yeahhh….. =)
mmm….everything looks good. that restaurant is one of my boss’ favorite restaurants in the city. i’ve never been there but i’m gonna try!
the sea scallops and the desserts looks delish!
I don’t know how NY is but Vegas’ is known for their chocolate, which I still find very so-so and tres American ironically. The scallops look wonderful. Is it me or does the consomme and the ‘lobster’ dish look greasy?
has anyone ever gotten 7 smiley faces? you’re a tough critic~
Those scallops look gorgeous. They’re sooo round! =D -L
I have a problem reminding myself to not come to your site when I’m hungry. Those scallops look AMAZING!!!
looks so yumm!! I’ve been dying to do Aureole. Although, it’s pretty clear which entree was the RestaurantWeek offering. That’s the thing about most Rest.Week places….they offer you chicken and salmon as the entree choices, when you really want their signature beef wellington or lobster 2-ways. I don’t blame 2 of your 3 for ordering off the regular menu.
the desserts look the best!! but all in all, everything looks delicious there. is restaurant week still going on?
the desserts and scallopes look really good,but the amuse boushe,tortellini and soup look like theyre covered in oil.
the scallops looks like its about to burst.
great website!!love your reviews about ny eateries cuz thats where i live =)
Those scallops definitely looks enticing.
I’m not sure if this food joint was ever mentioned in your site, but when you feel like having wings and around Chelsea area, hit up.
Tebaya
144 W 19th St
New York, NY
For some cheap yet delicious wings.
wow, these dishes remind me lots about NY, I’ll try “Seared Maine Sea Scallops”, when I go back next time.